Posts Tagged Barack Obama
Jimmy Carter’s race statements are right, but at odds with Obama’s Plutonian race strategy
When Jimmy Carter says it’s about race, I believe him to be as true as his boiled peanut recipe.
But Carter’s bluntness in his comments to NBC that the animosity toward Obama is race-based, is much too direct for Obama’s current style, and could upset the president’s momentum.
Obama is too cool for direct. Apparently, his race politics are way too subtle for the country.
The way Barack Obama has become a winner in politics is by diffusing the race issue and making it seem irrelevant.
In the Obama universe, issues don’t revolve around race. In this political solar system, race isn’t at the center like the Sun.
It’s more like Pluto.
It really is the formula to Obama’s success, and his new politics of bringing the country together. That’s not to mean he’s a Clarence Thomas , or that he forgets the importance of ethnicity and race in public policy.
It’s just that he knows race bogs down everything . It’s polarizing. And it prevents him reaching the kinds of compromise that helps one effectively lead an entire country.
So he sidesteps it.
Obama’s compromise on race is to show up, make it obvious he’s a black president, but not to dwell on it. For Obama, race is more the subtle subtext and not the raging headline. It was his secret to his campaign and his success.
And it throws the GOP off-track. They don’t know how to deal with a 21st Century Race politician.
When the GOP can’t argue the facts, as in health care, or when it can’t stem the support for the president on real issues, then it goes ad hominem and race is the old standby. The whole birth certificate issue and the Islamic middle name issue are nothing more than racist attacks on Obama.
Of course, all the stumbling around on race is based on how most people don’t want to admit racism is happening or even in existence. It plays to the moral conscience of both the white perps and the white liberals, who think they are perfect. Aren’t we all better than that? We’ve gone beyond race, right?
Well, not exactly.
So when Maureen Dowd writes her NY Times column about essentially saying, “Damn, we got racism here;” And when Jimmy Carter, our Southern gentleman, starts talking from the heart about racism at play in the policy debate, well then, by gum, we have racism.
What are we going to do about it?
I’m starting to see the wisdom of the Obama strategy. He’s just figured out a way to deal with race so he can get things done. The answer. Don’t deal with it.
It’s a tad zen-like.
By comparison, those who know the old politics on race are like cold warriors. Maybe we should try to do as Obama and ignore all this and try to press on, hoping that policies and people can change, and that by focusing on the bigger picture we can all be led to a new place together. Does that sound too grandiose or Lincolnesque? So be it. To do otherwise, is to bog down in the past, polarize, and get no where. Didn’t Obama show us that?
Maybe this is another one of those times that race bubbles up in Obama’s path, like the Rev.Wright affair. That means one sure-fire prescription could work now: A little speech therapy to put everything back into order in the Obama political universe, where race is minor.
As I said, race is not the Sun, it’s more like Pluto, making the strategy absolutely Plutonian.
Barack Obama, Carter on race, health care, Jimmy Carter, politics, race
Dowd on Wilson’s outburst: I guess it takes a white person or two to recognize an act of racism
Posted by Amok in blog, diversity, journalism, news on September 13th, 2009
Any other claim from a person of color gets automatically dismissed as more of that old, tired reverse-racist grievance politics. It’s usually accompanied with a scornful response like “Grow up, you old race dinosaur. Get a life. Get real. We have a black man as president. Join the 21st century.”
Insisting that the racist tendencies of America are still operating on all cylinders gets you that kind of reaction.
And then, because the racism is so obvious, and no one hears your cry, one tends to accept it as the reality of the new America. Save the wails for the extreme cases. Crying racism about the norm just doesn’t make it today.
That is, unless a white liberal columnist like Maureen Dowd finally gets it enough to wake up her white readers in the New York Times about a certain Southern congressman’s outcry during President Barack Obama’s health care address last week.
Said Rep. Joe Wilson (R-South Carolina) to the President: “You lie!”
The president didn’t of course. Not like George W. Bush ever did.
But Wilson’s charge has since made him a hero and darling to those who share his same segregationist values. Wilson is a Son of Confederate Veterans, who fights for the rights to wave the Dixie flag and decries the truth of segregationist Strom Thurmond’s bi-racial child as a smear.
Wilson has a difficult time with the truth. But his outburst made Dowd realize a truth:
In today’s column, “Boy, oh, boy” Dowd wrote: “I’ve been loath to admit that the shrieking lunacy of the summer — the frantic efforts to paint our first black president as the Other, a foreigner, socialist, fascist, Marxist, racist, Commie, Nazi; a cad who would snuff old people; a snake who would indoctrinate kids — had much to do with race.
I tended to agree with some Obama advisers that Democratic presidents typically have provoked a frothing response from paranoids — from Father Coughlin against F.D.R. to Joe McCarthy against Truman to the John Birchers against J.F.K. and the vast right-wing conspiracy against Bill Clinton.
But Wilson’s shocking disrespect for the office of the president — no Democrat ever shouted “liar” at W. when he was hawking a fake case for war in Iraq — convinced me: Some people just can’t believe a black man is president and will never accept it.”
Welcome to the ethnic truth, Maureen. Those of us who write primarily for the ethnic media have heard the drumbeats loudly before Wilson’s shout. Hopefully your readers will snap to, as you have.
With race as a subtext, Wilson shows that health care reform led by America’s first black president is made to order for those who yearn for the second coming of the civil war.
Barack Obama, Confederate south, health care, Joe Wilson, Maureen Dowd, South Carolina
Health-care Rx:Obama’s Speech Therapy
Whenever it seems like his back his to the wall, or the when “the sale” is in jeopardy, Obama’s prescription has always been the same: Give “the speech.”
That’s the way it was in campaign mode. And even after winning the presidency, it’s never let up for Obama. When the Rev. Wright stories appeared to sink his chances last year, an eloquent speech on race in Philly set the record straight. In January, a thoughtful inaugural sought to quell partisanship and indeed brought the country together. That is, until he set his attention to health care.
Now when health care is more polarizing than even race, Obama turned to his rhetorical gifts once again to forcefully lay it our for the people.
The speech was emotional and direct in the way it pared down his plan to the big picture essentials. Not the details,necessarily, but the larger view. A government-run not for profit insurance option for those without coverage, a public option, is still the most polarizing thing on the table. But what’s to fear? Competition is good. There’s a reason existing health care companies don’t want the uninsured. If government competition can force companies to lighten up their restrictions or improve their efficiencies to see the uninsured as a profit center, than that’s better than a bailout. And more people get insured.
The speech also exposed the partisan bickering and ad hominem for what it is. Save that b.s. for football season.
On the stuff that matters, Obama was authoritative, presidential, and appealed to the best in all Americans.
Now is the time to get the best wonks from both sides of the aisle and get a deal done.
If that really happens, chalk one up to Obama’s speech therapy.
Ling and Lee are free: All it took was a former president
Posted by Amok in blog, journalism, news, politics on August 4th, 2009
If you were wondering where Al Gore has been in the diplomatic effort to free his two employees jailed in North Korea, Bill Clinton provided you the answer.
Gore wasn’t big enough.
It takes a former president with with enormous global charisma to do what was needed to produced Laura Ling and Euna Lee. the two journalists with Gore’s Current TV found guilty of being in the wrong place at the wrong time in North Korea.
Jimmy Carter wasn’t big enough. Bush I and II? Are you kidding?
The North Koreans wanted Bill Clinton over for dinner. And they got him.
Once I heard Clinton was heading to see Kim Jong Il, I knew it would be just a matter of days that the pawns in question would be produced, safely in all his high drama.
Now the question is what does the U.S. give up in exchange. Clinton is a start, but it’s just the beginning to a real transition to…..?
It’s unclear. Currently, there are no official diplomatic ties between the U.S. and North Korea. So Clinton going as an unofficial offical keeps the status quo both in check, but potentially in flux. Obama and Clinton can maintain their hardline. But Kim Jong Il gets to show all his people that he still has standing, with or without nukes. He’s got Bill Clinton over for kimchee and a photo op.
Americans are supposed to be puzzled as to what’s next.
But if you’re in North or South Korea, you’ve got to be in awe.
If you’re starving in North Korea, you have hope today. U.S. recognition brings the possibility of change. If you’re in Seoul, you have to worry. If you’re in either country and you doubted the power of his hairness in North Korea, you are simply starstruck. The guy who looks like he’s on his death bed still has some juice. He got Bubba to stop b, and all the players got a little something.
Clinton got to ride into the sunset the hero. You think Clinton hesitated to be in that role, one-upping both his wife and the current president (both of whom were admittedly hamstrung). Clinton’s stock rises.
It certainly was worth it to Kim Jong Il.
And Laura Ling and Euna Lee ?
They now come home safely, with the story of their lives.
Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, diplomacy, Euna Lee, Hillary Clinton, Journalists in North Korea, Laura Ling, North Korea
Obama’s affirmative action for Muslims, Harvard Class Day, my day
Barack Obama couldn’t be Harvard Class Day speaker yesterday for obvious reasons. He was too busy preparing to reach out to his Muslim brothers and sisters.
Outreach to Muslims? This is affirmative action the U.S. can really use.
Policy-wise, Obama’s address could have been a speech George W. Bush would have given. The end goal of Obama’s comments essentially is a two-state solution exactly what Bush was pushing in the end.
But what a difference the messenger makes.
Would you say that Bush had a credibility problem? He only helped perpetuate the white stereotype that Obama referred to in his speech. Of course, it’s no different from the way Bin Laden feeds the Muslim stereotypes Americans know and love.
They all get in the way of communication.
But with a new messenger before them, the Muslim audience saw a new global leader in whom they could see a bit of a reflection of themselves. It was worth another look at the New America.
“I’ve come here to Cairo to seek a new beginning between the United States and Muslims around the world,” said Obama. “One based on mutual interest and mutual respect.”
With Obama’s background in Indonesia, his parentage, his cultural connection comes a new kind of diplomatic tone that may prove to be a more productive path to a lasting peace.
It’s a personal touch, the kind that comes with a new messenger. Denigrate Obama’s Muslim outreach as just a pretty speech. We are in a phase, amid war and terror, where one cannot make light of pretty speech.
Obama was plenty tough on both Israel and Hamas. Masked in pretty speech, it may help all sides see and value their common interests.
CLASS DAY
So Obama was at a university in Cairo and not Cambridge. Not at Harvard. But Matt Lauer was.
On the “The Today” show, Lauer talked about being the Harvard Class Day speaker: “Giving a speech to Harvard students and their parents and the faculty is just nerve-wracking and I admit it was intimidating.”
I can relate. I gave the student speech before the Class Day speaker in 1977 (George Plimpton that year). And it was intimidating. And exhilarating. It was a funny speech making fun of Harvard. So, of course, it got laughs. And one big one, I’ll never forget.
As I look back, I have given many speeches, but because of the setting the students, the parents, and the faculty that Lauer talked about, it was special.
I look to replicate that feeling every time I step to a podium.
Barack Obama, Cairo University, Harvard, Matt Lauer, Muslim, Muslim speech
Context? Here’s what Sotomayor said in 2001; Was it racist?
Sometimes you need more than the soundbite. In the new racist war being waged by conservatives over the nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court, it seems that there’s an attempt to stymie the new emerging politics of diversity with the polarizing old politics of angry white men.
It’s so 1994.
Going back to the hate politics of a previous decade doesn’t get us anywhere we need to be.
So I admit to being a little puzzled by how conservatives like Rush Limbaugh continue to call Sotomayor a racist for comments made in Berkeley in 2001.
The phrase that conservatives are in a tizzy about is bolded below.But you tell me if there’s an ounce of racism when you see how the phrase came up in her talk in Berkeley in 2001.
“Justice O’Connor has often been cited as saying that a wise old man and wise old woman will reach the same conclusion in deciding cases. I am not so sure Justice O’Connor is the author of that line since Professor Resnik attributes that line to Supreme Court Justice Coyle. I am also not so sure that I agree with the statement. First, as Professor Martha Minnow has noted, there can never be a universal definition of wise. Second, I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life.
“Let us not forget that wise men like Oliver Wendell Holmes and Justice Cardozo voted on cases which upheld both sex and race discrimination in our society. Until 1972, no Supreme Court case ever upheld the claim of a woman in a gender discrimination case. I, like Professor Carter, believe that we should not be so myopic as to believe that others of different experiences or backgrounds are incapable of understanding the values and needs of people from a different group. Many are so capable. As Judge Cedarbaum pointed out to me, nine white men on the Supreme Court in the past have done so on many occasions and on many issues including Brown.
“However, to understand takes time and effort, something that not all people are willing to give. For others, their experiences limit their ability to understand the experiences of others. Other simply do not care. Hence, one must accept the proposition that a difference there will be by the presence of women and people of color on the bench. Personal experiences affect the facts that judges choose to see. My hope is that I will take the good from my experiences and extrapolate them further into areas with which I am unfamiliar. I simply do not know exactly what that difference will be in my judging. But I accept there will be some based on my gender and my Latina heritage.”
These judges aren’t robots. They’re human. They have feelings and experiences that will inform their decisions. That’s why a diverse America needs a diverse high court,one that creates a certain empathy for all those seeking justice. Empathy alone won’t return a favorable decision. But it will assure anyone who stands before the court that no perspectives were overlooked. That’s what a diverse bench promises, a sense of fairness and justice for all.
Embracing the race issue: Obama’s Sotomayor pick an inspiring Affirmative Action success story
American Filipinos, like most people of color, know the life of Sonia Sotomayor, the woman picked by President Obama to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court. If empathy was one of the criteria, Sotomayor has no problem when it comes to Filipinos. Her story is practically our story.
With the Philippines connected to Puerto Rico as pawns in the Spanish American War, our heritage alone makes us natural allies. Sotomayor’s parents came from Puerto Rico to America looking for opportunity. They arrived in New York and grew up in public housing in the Bronx.
If you’re from San Francisco like I am, read that as Geneva Towers, Hunter’s Point, or Potrero Hill. Like I said, we share a life, a pattern, and are fortunate to have had opportunities to break it. As a young girl in Catholic school, Sotomayor was identified as a promising student. For many children of color, this would begin in the late ’60s and early ’70s. Elite secondary schools and universities began to plant seeds throughout the country, hoping to grow a new generational pool of talent for the nation.
As an American Filipino, I was one of those chosen. So were young Latinas like Sotomayor, who chose Princeton, then Yale Law School. She was on the fast track and succeeded every step.
Now, nearly two generations later, the real harvest occurs. No one can say there are few qualified minorities after such a lengthy period of social nurturing.
The degrees of success vary, of course. But the large middle- and upper-middle class in America is a direct result of those years of opportunity. As a testament to that, this week President Obama could choose a Latina woman who has been nominated in the past by both Democratic and Republican presidents for successively higher federal court positions. That alone speaks volumes about the success of a much-maligned social strategy to equality: affirmative action. It works.
When administered properly by identifying qualified and talented candidates, affirmative action remains a strategy that can help bring true diversity to America at every level of society.
At the base of affirmative action is merit. It’s allowing people who wouldn’t have a chance an opportunity to compete. That’s not racist compared to the all-white institutions and envirnonments affirmative action was intended to fix.
Of course, these days, you’ll never hear affirmative action mentioned. It’s not even euphemized like calling terror “enhanced interrogation techniques.” If the phrase “affirmative action” was said at the Obama press conference this week, I didn’t hear it. It’s political death.
Instead you heard the president talk about Sotomayor’s American Dream. You heard about how she grew up in the projects and got to Yale Law School.
It was basically my admission essay to Harvard in 1972. It’s a good story. It works. At the press conference, you also heard about baseball, and how as a federal judge in New York, it was Sotomayor’s decision in 1995 that sided with the players and ended the baseball strike. What a gal! American Dream and Baseball. Sounds like the first Latina to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court!
The Obama administration has chosen to sell the judge in this feel-good fashion to avoid all the hot buttons of race.
But there’s nothing wrong with confronting the hot-buttons with Sotomayor.
There’s a reason she was nominated up the judge chain by both G.H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton. She’s good and qualified, emphasis on that second point.
And she’s a woman and a Latina. The administration is finally showing that race really matters.
Straddling Colorblind
For all of President Obama’s underplaying of race in his political demeanor to the point of colorblindness, his Supreme Court pick says it all. To his credit, he still values the pigment and the numbers. In this era of diversity, we need to see the reflection of America in everything we hold dear. And that means making sure people of color show up. Race politics is alive and well.
Naysayers may cry out that that leads to quotas, which are, of course, illegal. But no one is talking about quotas. On the contrary, we should all hope that this appointment leads to more harvesting of the seeds of affirmative action, a proven remedy to racial injustice.
Sotomayor, self-described as an ordinary person blessed with extraordinary opportunities, is a living example of affirmative action done right. She shows what happens when gifted and talented people of promise from under-served communities are given a chance. They excel. They succeed.
Sotomayor’s “American Dream” tale is attractive. But people shouldn’t forget that her life is the blueprint model of how affirmative action–when it is administered correctly–is supposed to work. A little girl from the projects can be part of the highest court of the land. Sotomayor’s nomination should be a boost to all people of color that the dream of opportunity is still alive.
It’s a definite sign that President Obama, who has taken the elevator up, has not forgotten to send it back down.
I haven’t seen such a clear sign of hope for America in a long, long time.
-
Recent Posts
- California nurses call for investigation of alleged discriminatory hiring practices against Filipinos at SF’s St.Luke’s hospital
- Note from Emil Guillermo: Help,I’m a pioneer!
- Emil Guillermo: Confessions of a bad relative
- Sherrod story a racial speed bump, but shows Obama’s preferred passive stance on race
What's on my mind now...
- At first, the rally was Beck's version of affirmative action (just no Asians). Then it morphed into the kickoff for his American Holy War. 1 week ago
- Beck's use of MLK isOrwellian. Lots of color on stage, but purpose isn't unity. It's to lay foundation for an American religious war. 1 week ago
- Is there a "ban" on hiring Filipino nurses at SF's St.Luke Hospital? The nurses union want an investigation. go to http://www.amok.com 3 weeks ago
- Half life of a twitter ...4 minutes accordint to aaja panel on social media. 2010-08-06
- I'll be there for opening reception. And then in and out. We'll connect. 2010-07-30
- @bonagogo that's why tweeting God is infinitely better! He also forgives typus. in reply to bonagogo 2010-07-23
- @bonagogo yeah she could whip that messi guy for real. Happy July 3rd! in reply to bonagogo 2010-07-03
- 4 zip final. Messi excuse? Energy zapped by late night tango. #arg ugh. Spain Dutch final. The winner plays Serena Williams. 2010-07-03
- #worldcup2010 germany 3, maradona-messi hype ZERO. The work on the pitch beat the Pitch. Messi didn't show up for the cup. 2010-07-03
- #vegetarian Enjoy Restaurant on kearney in san fran is better veg food than millineum or greens. Real value, real quality for all. Yum. 2010-07-03
- More updates...
Posting tweet...
Archives
Other Sites
Emil's blog and column in AsianWeek.
Emil's column in The Philippine News.
Emil's archived column on SF Gate.Press
AAJA: Emil Guillermo Wins NAM Award for Best Blogger
New America Media: Winners of the 2009 Northern California Ethnic Media AwardsClick to hear a message from Emil
Tags
"24 ABC Add new tag Asian American Asian American Pacific Islander Heritage month Barack Obama baseball Cairo University California politics California primary campaign finance Carly Fiorina Cory Aquino Deepwater Horizon spill Euna Lee Harvard health care Henry Louis Gates Imelda Marcos Joseph Estrada journalism Laura Ling Manny Pacquiao Manny Villar Marcos Matt Lauer Meg Whitman Miguel Cotto Muslim Muslim speech Noynoy Aquino Obama Philippine elections Philippine presidential elections Philippines President Obama race Rod McLeod San Francisco politics San Francisco Superior Court judges race SCOTUS pick Skip Gates Sonia Sotomayor Supreme Court Tiger Woods


